Saint Theo's Menu (Update 2025)

At Saint Theo's in New York, patrons can expect a trendy and upscale Italian dining experience with outdoor seating and a full bar. Despite mixed reviews on the food quality, customers praise the creative and delicious menu offerings, particularly the Mezzaluna appetizer and Full Italian brunch option. The ambiance at Saint Theo's is described as vibey and stylish, with a modern Italian aesthetic that exudes elegance. While some diners may find the prices a bit steep for the overall dining experience, the quality of ingredients and attention to detail in each dish shine through. Additionally, the restaurant offers a unique setting with a hidden Venice Bar, adding to the allure of the dining experience. Overall, Saint Theo's presents an opportunity to enjoy Italian-inspired cuisine in a chic and lively atmosphere.

Appetizers

FRIED CALAMARI

Romesco

$23.00

MOZZARELLA IN CARROZZA

fried mozzarella, raw tomato sauce, parmesan

$25.00

BAR PIE

tomato, mozzarella, grana padano

$23.00

CAESAR PIE

little gem, spicy breadcrumbs

$24.00

BIANCO

prosciutto, red onion, arugula

$26.00

Pizzettes

Salads

ARUGULA SALAD

balsamic vinaigrette, bianco sardo

$22.00

CAESAR SALAD

parmesan, rosemary croutons

$22.00

CHICORY

fiore sardo, honeycrisp apple, pistachio

$22.00

CHOPPED

iceberg, pepperoncini, salami picante

$22.00

CHERRY TOMATO

zucchini, spaghetti, basil

$25.00

PESTO FUSILLI

basil, grana padano, lemon

$26.00

RICOTTA TORCHIO

buffalo ricotta, chili oil

$29.00

HONEYNUT SQUASH AGNOLOTTI

spinach, ricotta, parmesan

$30.00

SHORT RIB RAGU

pappardelle, grana padano

$34.00

LOBSTER LINGUINI

calabrian chili, roasted tomato, basil

$42.00

Pasta

Entrees

HALF BRANZINO

gigante beans, broccoli di ciccio, orange gremolata

$44.00

SWORDFISH

prosciutto di san daniele, frisse, orange vinaigrette

$45.00

NY STRIP

smashed fingerling potato, salsa verde

$65.00

CHICKEN MILANESE

arugula, cherry tomato, bianco sardo

$34.00

LAMB CHOPS

honeynut squash, farro, spigarello

$68.00

BROCCOLI RABE

garlic oil, chili flakes, lemon zest

$16.00

NEW POTATOES

garlic, olive oil, parsley

$16.00

ROASTED CARROTS

pistachio, shallot, balsamico

$18.00

Sides

Dessert

TIRAMISU

$17.00